POST-OP: The Responsive Eye - Fifty Years After
THE Magazine, April 2015
Susan Wider

As a fifty-year-anniversary tribute to the Museum of Modern Art's February 1965 exhibition The Responsive Eye, David Richard Gallery presents POST-OP, curated by David Eichholtz and Peter Frank. The Responsive Eye introduced the Op Art movement through the work of ninety-nine international artists. POST-OP investigates how a subset of these artists continues to work with visual perception and perceptual ambiguity. This is the first in a series of four linked exhibitions by Eichholtz and Frank in this anniversary year.

MoMA’s original press release for the exhibition characterized the more than one hundred twenty paintings and constructions as works that exist “less as objects to be examined than as generators of perceptual responses in the eye and mind of the viewer.” In David Richard Gallery’s large, bright space, the works undulate, vibrate, and dart; it’s like being surrounded by color-drenched, dancing shapes. The artists use lines, bands, circles, and patterns in white, gray, black, or vivid colors to create movement, illusions, and hidden images—all of which are real to the eye and the brain, but do not exist physically in the actual paintings. In the original exhibition catalogue for The Responsive Eye, William C. Seitz, MoMA’s Curator of Painting and Sculpture Exhibitions, writes, “The eye needs only the slightest clue to link an abstract shape to some past association with actual objects and space.”

In POST-OP, Karl Benjamin’s two works from 1964 and 1990 both present dense, bold colors, the first in large blocks, the second in multicolored geometric patterns that shift into ever-changing prisms. It’s a mistake to try to figure out where one prism stops and the next one starts. Just when you think you know where one plane recedes, it jumps forward on you. Richard Anuszkiewicz’s Exact Quantity, from 1963, is anything but. It would be terrifying to try to ascertain the exact quantity of these lines as they cross different colors and create different sensations. Some push us backward, others tip the painting’s two large squares sideways, but they really don’t. Up close, they aren’t squares at all, merely illusions. Looking more intently, or squinting to try to understand what is really there, is a recipe for motion sickness. And yet we’re fascinated to try. After all, didn’t the artist have to focus on these bouncing lines for extended periods to create this effect in the first place?

Untitled (June 30) by Ernst Benkert, from 1967, along with Francis Celentano’s Elliptical Kinetic Painting, from the same year, toss us around in black and white—literally in Celentano’s case, as there is a motor involved. Benkert presents squares that might not be, and even though our brains know that this ink-on-paper creation is perfectly fl at, and hanging on a perfectly flat wall, the upper left and lower right corners still curl away from us. They just do. Then Celentano loops us around and around with black and white ellipses in order to pull us into a black hole. Surely the ellipses must be a connected spiral, but they turn out to be nine separate white bands alternating with nine black ones. Correction—they don’t just pull us into the black hole, they pull us right through the wall. Because the piece is motorized to spin continuously, it also creates the sensation of pushing us out while it sucks us in. A more recent Celentano acrylic in nearly neon colors is equally unnerving, yet gorgeous. Le Cirque 10, from 2004, blends graded wiggles of greens, reds, ranges, and probably several other colors, except that you can’t look at it long enough to really pick them out because the floor is starting to move. The effect is something like a multicolored, pounding, shimmering waterfall. Eichholtz, who designed the exhibition layout, chose to enhance this effect when he hung Le Cirque 10 on a wall that receives powerful, natural New Mexico light. Access to the painting is from either side, which causes the ripples to undulate from top to bottom. No, wait, that can’t be, it’s a flat surface.

John Goodyear illuminates his 1965 work The Light Source from behind. Doesn’t matter, we still reach out to steady ourselves. There is a yellow-and-black pattern on the surface of a light box. A panel of horizontal acrylic bars hangs in front of it. When the panel is pushed sideways into a pendulum motion, the yellow lines jump to life behind it and even our own movement changes the patterns. Goodyear’s Presence, from 2013, incorporates wooden dowels and monofilament in a way that is entirely unsteadying. Two of the four vertical bars are painted on the canvas. The other two alternate with them but are suspended in front of the canvas. Our eye is ready to believe that all four are painted fl at until we notice the dowels’ gentle shadows. The powerful red, white, and blue bands in Francis Hewitt’s 1991 Franklin County actually feel calming. There is so much going on within each band that our eyes don’t fight to dissect it all. Instead, we see an explosion of colors. On a flat surface, it stays that way. And nothing dances. But not to worry, Hewitt’s Grey Illuminated Discs and Op Ended, both from 1964, prance on the wall with fantastic vibrations. Another Hewitt wallbender is Illuminated Discs, also from 1964. Here are circles that look like Japanese lanterns meet Bubble Wrap, as the lower left corner of the painting appears to flap off the wall toward us.

Thomas Downing’s ca. 1970 Fizi looks simple: three circles—each of a different blue hue—that make the square painting seem narrower on the bottom. And then the circles begin to lose the definition along their curves, their sizes shift, and there go our eyes and minds again, running away from us with their own ideas. In a later acrylic from 1983 called First Sky, Downing continues to mess with us. Are the red, feathery shapes the same size? Are the pinks alike? Are the parallel lines truly parallel?

Happily, each artist’s contribution from the 1960s and his contrasting later work are not presented side by side. Instead, Eichholtz has placed the older works in the gallery’s inner core, with the newer pieces around the perimeter, like moving back in time. We can now look forward to parts two through four of the series, with the possibility of a four-series catalogue coming, like a prize, at the conclusion.

Susan Wider

Download:   POST-OP: The Responsive Eye - Fifty Years After
THE Magazine, April 2015
Susan Wider

Associated Artist

• Richard Anuszkiewicz
• Karl Benjamin
• Ernst Benkert
• Francis Celentano
• Thomas Downing
• Lorser Feitelson
• John Goodyear
• Francis Hewitt
• Leroy Lamis
• Mon Levinson
• Alexander Liberman
• Ed Mieczkowski
• Oli Sihvonen
• Julian Stanczak
• Peter Anthony Stroud
• Tadasky

Associated Exhibitions

• Post-Op: 'The Responsive Eye' Fifty Years After Curated by David Eichholtz and Peter Frank
  February 24, 2015 - April 11, 2015
  MORE INFO

Associated News

• May 23, 2020
  Richard Anuszkiewicz (1930–2020)


• August 5, 2019
  ‘Optical Art’ to be shown at Fort Wayne Museum of Art
  Wane.com
  August 5, 2019
  Dirk Rowley
  


• April 8, 2019
  JULIAN STANCZAK
  The Lobby Gallery, 499 Park Avenue, New York
  On view through September 2019
  Reception: Tuesday, April 9, 5-7 pm
  
  


• March 26, 2019
  Rhythm, Rhythm, Everywhere
  Toledo City Paper, 03/26/2019
  Thena Cocoves
  
  


• August 24, 2018
  The Eye of the Beholder Tadasky
  Santa Fe New Mexican
  Pasatiempo, 08/24/2018
  Michael Abatemarco
  
  


• August 10, 2018
  Press Release - Tadasky 'Pushing Boundaries'


• July 28, 2018
  Unique art 'treasure hunt' spans dozens of Ohio venues
  The Blade, 07/28/2018
  Roberta Gedert
  
  


• July 12, 2018
  Cleveland Hopes to Become the Next Venice
  The Wall Street Journal, 07/12/2018
  Kelly Crow
  
  


• February 17, 2018
  Julian Stanczak
  Visual Art Source, 02/17/2018
  Amanda Malloy
  
  


• February 9, 2018
  Julian Stanczak at David Richard Gallery
  Santa Fe New Mexican
  Pasatiempo, 02/09/2018
  Michael Abatemarco
  
  


• February 8, 2018
  Love is in the Art
  Santa Fe Arts Journal, 02/08/2018
  Emily Van Cleve
  
  


• January 31, 2018
  Press Release - Julian Stanczak "Dynamic Fields"


• January 26, 2018
  Oli Sihvonen, Kinetic Energy
  Wall Street International Magazine, 01/26/2018
  
  


• January 17, 2018
  Press Release - Oli Sihvonen "Kinetic Energy"


• July 22, 2017
  FRONT International: Cleveland Triennial for Contemporary Art


• April 19, 2017
  Julian Stanczak’s Contribution to Cincinnati Art
  City Beat, 04/19/2017
  Steven Rosen
  
  


• April 11, 2017
  Julian Stanczak, Abstract Painter, Dies at 88
  New York Times, 04/11/2017
  Roberta Smith
  
  


• March 31, 2017
  Julian Stanczak on the Power of Red
  ArtInfo, 03/31/2017
  
  


• March 28, 2017
  Op Art Loses One of Its Leading Figures With Death of Julian Stanczak
  ArtNet News, 03/29/2017
  Perwana Nazif
  
  


• March 28, 2017
  Julian Stanczak, Central Figure of Op Art Movement, Dies at 88
  ArtNet News, 03/28/2017
  Alex Greenberger
  
  


• March 28, 2017
  Julian Stanczak (1928–2017)
  Artforum, 03/28/2017
  
  


• March 27, 2017
  Julian Stanczak, globally renowned Op artist based in Cleveland, has died at age 88
  Cleveland.com, 03/25/2017
  Steven Litt, The Plain Dealer
  
  


• December 16, 2015
  Julian Stanczak Op Art paintings smash local price ceiling and rocket nationally
  Cleveland.com, 12/16/2015
  Steven Litt
  
  


• February 25, 2015
  Op Art pioneer Richard Anuszkiewicz’s dancing colors are like Red Bull for your retinas
  Orlando Weekly, 02/25/2015
  Richard Reep
  
  


• January 29, 2015
  Color Color' evokes harmony between two disparate mediums
  The New Record, 01/29/2015
  Christina Drobney
  
  


• December 15, 2014
  'Color Color' at the Cincinnati Art Museum showcases digital prints and poetry
  ArtDaily.org, 12/15/2014
  
  


• March 19, 2014
  Oli Sihvonen: In Motion
  Art Ltd, March/April 2014
  Matthew Irwin
  
  


• March 3, 2014
  Press Release - Julian Stanczak "Lineal Pathways"


• March 1, 2014
  Oli Sihvonen
  David Richard Gallery, Santa Fe, New Mexico
  Visual Art Source, 03/01/2014
  Iris McLister
  
  


• February 23, 2014
  1969 Cleveland Arts Prize for Visual Arts
  


• January 31, 2014
  Capturing chance and time


• January 30, 2014
  Rhythmic and optical paintings by Oli Sihvonen from 1988 to 1991 presented at David Richard Gallery
  


• January 10, 2014
  Press Release - Oli Sihvonen "In Motion"


• November 15, 2013
  Richard Anuszkiewicz featrured in the exhibition "Optic Nerve" at the Tacoma Art Museum.


• April 30, 2013
  JULIAN STANCZAK
  COLOR WONDER
  Cleveland Magazine, May 2013
  
  


• April 13, 2013
  Press Release - RICHARD ANUSZKIEWICZ Variations: Evolution of The Artist's Media 1986 - 2012


• April 8, 2013
  AKRON ART MUSEUM
  Line Color Illusion: 40 Years of Julian Stanczak
  Apr 13, 2013 - Nov 3, 2013
  


• October 16, 2012
  THE MARKET'S HOTTEST ARTISTS
  Bloomberg.com, 10/16/2012
  Ben Steverman
  
  


• August 8, 2012
  Press Release - Tadasky "The Circle Reviewed: 1964 to 2012"


• May 1, 2012
  An Interview with Artist Julian Stanczak
  GeoForm, May 2012
  Julie Karabenick
  
  


• May 1, 2012
  An Interview with Artist Julian Stanczak
  GeoForm, May 2012
  Julie Karabenick
  
  


• December 13, 2011
  JULIAN STANCZAK: GREAT COLORIST OF THE 20TH CENTURY
  Cleveland Institute of Art, 12/13/2011
  
  


• November 6, 2011
  Cleveland Institute of Art touts its own history in shows on Robert Mangold, Julian Stanczak and Ed Mieczkowski
  Cleveland.com, 11/06/2011
  Steven Litt
  
  


• September 21, 2011
  CLEVELAND MUSEUM OF ART OPTICAL ART EXHIBIT A TEST FOR THE EYES
  WEWS, 09/21/2011
  
  


• August 23, 2011
  Press Release - Julian Stanczak "Tactile See Through"


• November 1, 2010
  The New Criterion review of "Julian Stanczak: Color - Grid"
  Gallery Chronicle, November 2010
  James Panero
  
  


• February 12, 2015
  Press Release - Post-Op: 'The Responsive Eye' Fifty Years After


• April 1, 2015
  POST-OP: The Responsive Eye - Fifty Years After
  THE Magazine, April 2015
  Susan Wider
  
  


• March 20, 2015
  'Post-Op' On View At David Richard
  Antiques and The Arts Weekly, 03/20/2015
  
  


• March 4, 2015
  Responding to “The Responsive Eye”: A Santa Fe Gallery
  Showcases Op Art’s Thriving Legacy
  Artsy.net, 03/04/2015
  Heather Corcoran